Pumpkin Pie Part Deux

The rest of the weekend baking project – kind of my own personal Iron Chef challenge – was around pumpkin.  Pumpkin is an interesting ingredient for me because as a child, I disliked both pumpkin and squash, to the extent that the flavor would literally make me gag.  I’m not sure why.  Maybe the flavor is kind of strong?  The one squash dish I did like was the squash rolls – a dinner roll made with some squash puree – so maybe that validates my theory, since the rolls didn’t have a very strong squash flavor.

I also didn’t like sweet potatoes, yams, and tofu as a child – all things that I just love now.  Another theory why I didn’t like them then was that I didn’t like them until I had them particularly well prepared.

(I’ll tread carefully with the next part of this entry because I know my mother reads this blog…)

My mother went through a big tofu phase sometime in the late 70s.  We lived in Northern California, meat was expensive, and tofu was all the rage as a healthy, inexpensive meat substitute.   My mother got hold of two cookbooks by Gary LandgrebeTofu Goes West and Tofu at Center Stage.  On the cover of the first cookbook was an illustration of a covered wagon being driven by a block of tofu.  On the second was a picture of a stage with a block of tofu tap dancing in the center of it.  No kidding.  I was able to find the books online still, but no cover pictures.

Anyhow, Landgrebe’s take on tofu was basically to substitute it anywhere a recipe might call for ground beef.

It wasn’t until junior high school, when I started hanging around with several first generation Chinese-American friends, that I finally learned to appreciate tofu.  The same probably goes for squash and pumpkin.  More exposure to the vegetables prepared in a greater variety of ways, has led me to really enjoy them even more.

Roasted root vegetables, with squash and sweet potatoes, for example.  Mixed with some olive oil and rosemary… mmm, yummy!

So it was with pumpkin pie.  Roka challenged me to make a pumpkin pie from scratch.  My first attempt was a few weeks ago.  It turned out okay so I bought a whole mess of pumpkins and decided to make several pies and, while at it, a recipe of pumpkin biscotti.  Tawn’s mother really likes biscotti and I haven’t made her any in a while.

P1030998 P1040003
P1040037 P1040038
P1040042 P1040045
P1040047 P1040049
P1040054 P1040056

The pie worked out quite well.  It isn’t that much extra work and the flavor is really lovely.  The pie crust is still an issue, though.  What the heck is going on with it?  I’m going to Cooks Illustrated to find out why I’m having so much trouble with it.  It tasted fine but the texture was all wrong.  After rolling it out, I couldn’t lift it up.  It just disintegrated!

Roka came over Monday night to try the pie.  Since I had two (and we didn’t want to scarf them down by ourselves although we certainly would have considered doing just that) I invited other people over.  Markus, his visiting mother and niece and nephew came over for what was, for them, a pre-dinner dessert.  I also served them some biscotti and baguette washed down with tea.

Roka really liked the pie.  Markus and family did, too, but it is Roka’s opinion I’m most interested in because she was the one who first challenged me to make a pumpkin pie from scratch.  She was sad, though, because she thought that since I had made a successful pumpkin pie that I would move on to other things and she wouldn’t get another one.  She drew this conclusion since she tried chocolate souffle for her first time two months ago, liked it, and I haven’t made it for her since!

The whipped cream looks a little funny on that pie, doesn’t it?  Markus picked up some whipping cream on his way over to try the pie and when I whipped it with my electric mixer, it never did really come together.  Not sure why.  Any theories or suggestions for me?


As for the biscotti, they turned out tasty but uninspiring.  I think they need some pecans or cranberries or white chocolate chips – or maybe a little bit of all three? – to give them some additional umph.

What’s next for the Iron Chef Thailand?  Nah, just kidding… I’m a noncompetitive cook.  My sister once suggested that we should have my cousin Patrick and I do an Iron Chef at a family reunion.  I’d rather we just plan a big meal together and prepare it.  This world is competitive enough without bringing it into the family kitchen.


5 thoughts on “Pumpkin Pie Part Deux

  1. Everything looks so delicious. In regards to the whipping cream, make sure the cream ice cold as well as the bowl which you will whip the cream in. Also, you could freeze the beaters from your electric mixer to make them ice cold. You could stick the bowl and beaters into the freezer for 10 to 20 minutes. Hope this helps!

  2. Everything looks wonderful!For the biscotti, how about dipping them in melted white chocolate?On the food network, Alton Brown did a whole episode on pie crust and the chemistry behind getting that perfect tender and flaky texture. Maybe it could help troubleshoot the problems you’re having. I’ll see if I have it on DVD.I’d like to put in my request to be on the guest list for the Iron Chef event at the next family reunion.

  3. Pumpkin biscotti with pecans. yummm. The whipped cream looks like you tried to whip half and half or regular milk. I think the fat content was less than it should have been?I totally want to be on the dinner guest list for the Patrick/Chris dinner. ;-D

  4. This is your Mother writing… I didn’t realize the pumpkin/squash dishes caused you so much trouble. I don’t think any of us really liked the tofu recipes to be honest. Life is full of growing even with food choices and likes/dislikes. Glad you’re on board now, however, with these wonderful foods full of flavor and so nutritious. The pie looks delicious. I think the cold utensils would help. Sandy’s comment about fat content would be worth looking into. I’ll email you my pie crust recipe. You can make comparisons and see what you think. Mom

  5. Hi there!  I enjoy reading your blog from time to time….and I am always left hungry afterwards!  By the way, regarding Biscotti, I have made them in the past and have had to experiment with ingredients.  Once made them with cornmeal (recipe I saw on Food Network) and well let’s just say never again!  I liked dipping half of each one in bittersweet chocolate and sprinkling with shaved almonds.
    Anyway, just wanted to introduce myself and say hello!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s